Legislators have forgotten how to dissent respectfully: SC on neta targeting Nitish


NEW DELHI: Commenting on the frequent acrimonious proceedings in assemblies and Parliament, the Supreme Court on Monday said that lawmakers seem to have forgotten how to be respectful while expressing strong disagreement or criticizing their opponents.
The comment came from a bench of Justices Surya Kant and NK Singh when RJD neta took charge. Sunil Kumar Singhself-challenge petition bihar legislative councilThe decision to expel him from the House for alleged misconduct and misdemeanor and imitating CM Nitish Kumar during the budget session.
“Members of the Augustan Chambers should be respectful of others even if they are their staunchest critics,” SC said, prima facie disapproving of Singh’s comments.
Sunil Kumar Singh’s lawyer AM Singhvi said though the matter is sub judice, the EC has announced a bypoll for Singh’s vacant seat, and understanding this would create confusion. Singhvi said that if elections are held and someone else is elected, and at the same time SC leaves out Singh’s expulsion, it would lead to an incongruent situation of having two candidates elected for the same seat. SC should call off elections scheduled for the end of this month, he pleaded.
SC refused to postpone the elections but said it would schedule the final hearing of Singh’s writ petition for January 9. Singhvi said, “Freedom of expression has been given ample latitude within a House.” The court said, “Is this how freedom of speech is used within the House? You (Singhvi) are also a Member of Parliament. Do you agree with the use of such language against opponents within a House?” Singhvi said he does not subscribe to that language, but that expulsion for using that language would leave opposition seats empty. “For a similar use of language by another MLC, he was simply suspended. But in Singh’s case, it was expulsion.”
The ethics committee of the legislative council in its report recommended Singh’s dismissal, stating that “being the chief whip of the opposition, his legislative responsibility and adaptation of rules and regulations should be greater than that of others. But his behavior It was different.
After entering the well, he raised wild slogans, hindered the functioning of the House, did not respect the instructions given to the President, used defamatory words against the leader of the House, trying to humiliate him and, in a way, damaged the dignity of the legislature. council.” According to the report, Singh was expelled on July 26.





Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *